all a / b / c / f / h / jp / l / o / q / s / sw / lounge cgi up wiki
[Home] [Catalog] [Search] [Inbox] [Write PM] [Admin]
[Return]

Posting mode: Reply
(for deletion, 8 chars max)
  • Allowed file types are: gif, jpg, jpeg, png, bmp, swf, webm, mp4
  • Maximum file size allowed is 50000 KB.
  • Images greater than 200 * 200 pixels will be thumbnailed.
File: top nominated 2024-10-29.png
(21 KB, 612x572)[ImgOps]
21 KB
No.67625
Since there's sum debate about it between staff-san, which of teh following should we do:

A. Alternate each month between long streams and short streams. We'll watch the top-nominated show(s) with a run-time equivalent to a 12-ep TV series (1-cour) one month, then the next month watch the top-nominated show(s) with a shorter run-time (as long as it isn't 🔞, but additional shows can be 🔞). The top-nominated show will occasionally be postponed until the following month (or longer depending on how votes change) depending on its length

B. Watch the top-nominated show(s) every month regardless of run-time. If it's significantly shorter than a 12-ep TV series, throw in 1 or more additional highly-nominated shorter shows to make it a double/triple-feature

For context, teh nominations for what we watch are here: https://cgi.heyuri.net/nominate/

If we choose option A (and assuming the rankings don't change), the November Heyuri Cytube stream will be Gunsmith Cats (#11) + Unbalance (#2 🔞)

If we choose option B, the November Heyuri Cytube stream will be Elfen Lied (#1)
Marked for deletion (Old)
>>
No.67626
I dont think it really matters, I just want 2 watch teh anime
>>
No.67627
for some more context, A was believed to be consensus after the tenth townhall so it was tried to be done that way since then. Below is logs with some unrelated messages removed. If we go with B, we will watch end up watching long anime way more often. B is practically making it every month without anything planned to keep teh "special feeling" of cytubes.

https://up.heyuri.net/src/3494.txt

[2024-05-11 19:36:27] anonwaha: ANONWAHA TOPIC #4: Heyuri Cytube. currently it's held once every 2 months - is that good, or should it be more/less often?
[2024-05-11 19:36:33] Lulz Master: i dont
[2024-05-11 19:36:37] nau: which one is teh real one!
[2024-05-11 19:36:38] Le AFK Man: i think 2 months is a good balance
[2024-05-11 19:36:41] Angel!: once a month!
[2024-05-11 19:36:43] Gaijin: MOAR OFTEN
[2024-05-11 19:36:46] 2048bytes: moar often
[2024-05-11 19:36:52] 2048bytes: once a month like angel said
[2024-05-11 19:36:52] Le AFK Man: i wouldnt mind moar often though
[2024-05-11 19:36:55] Hachikuji Mayoi: less often!
[2024-05-11 19:36:57] Apple: Personally I believe it should be once per month. Thoughts?
[2024-05-11 19:36:58] yakuruto: i vote to keep status quo
[2024-05-11 19:36:58] infinitelolz: i guess 2 month is a good balance but i still wish it was moar often
[2024-05-11 19:37:00] BlastFurnace: I like the idea of once per month, but 2 is acceptable
[2024-05-11 19:37:03] nau: i think once every 2 months is good!
[2024-05-11 19:37:08] not pez: Reason to haev it moore often is a reason to PROMOTE Heyurri, while i personally think 2 months
[2024-05-11 19:37:11] kaguya?V4Zyo2onG6: I would be fine with more often, but it could have less attendance and "special feeling" attached
[2024-05-11 19:37:24] BlastFurnace: it's good to have people excited for it to happen, and that would disappear if you did it too often
[2024-05-11 19:37:24] Le AFK Man: yeah, agreed
[2024-05-11 19:37:32] 2048bytes: hmmm makes sense!
[2024-05-11 19:37:34] yakuruto: i think if it were more often, people mite get sick of it
[2024-05-11 19:37:35] BlastFurnace: i think once per month would still be exciting but i see the logic of two
[2024-05-11 19:37:35] Angel!: though 2 month gives more time to vote!
[2024-05-11 19:37:37] Le AFK Man: if its every month people will get booared
[2024-05-11 19:37:42] BlastFurnace: maybe so
[2024-05-11 19:37:44] Hachikuji Mayoi: people would be less afraid to miss it if it was often
[2024-05-11 19:37:50] BlastFurnace: ah true
[2024-05-11 19:37:58] kaguya?V4Zyo2onG6: What about 12-episodes anime per 2 months, and some 2-episode OVAs in between?
[2024-05-11 19:38:00] Angel!: maybe 2 and a half months?
[2024-05-11 19:38:07] yakuruto: on the contrary, if it were often, i think people would feel they keep missing out
[2024-05-11 19:38:17] infinitelolz: kaguya: thats a nice alternative
[2024-05-11 19:38:27] Anonymous: i think kaguyas ide is good
[2024-05-11 19:38:38] BlastFurnace: i like that too
[2024-05-11 19:38:40] Angel!: nice!
[2024-05-11 19:38:40] anonwaha: what about the idea of having the top nominations once every 2 months, but having the less popular nominations in between?
[2024-05-11 19:38:44] ayaya: we can have smaller scale stream
[2024-05-11 19:38:51] BlastFurnace: I'm an OVA maniac and would be more excited for the weird random OVAs though :DDD
[2024-05-11 19:38:51] Angel!: smart!
[2024-05-11 19:38:59] 2048bytes: afk
[2024-05-11 19:39:06] yakuruto: tough decision, i like both ideas
[2024-05-11 19:39:06] kaguya?V4Zyo2onG6: it would be somehting like that anyways, most short anime are less popular in the standings
[2024-05-11 19:39:18] BlastFurnace: sadly :(
[2024-05-11 19:39:27] Anonymous: yeah, but short anime is wa<tched in bulk alot
[2024-05-11 19:39:32] yakuruto: if it is smaller OVAs in between, then having it more often isn't an issue
[2024-05-11 19:39:32] Anonymous: to make 12 eps
[2024-05-11 19:39:35] Gaijin: I need a friday evening stream, possibly on cytube or gikopoi?
[2024-05-11 19:39:38] BlastFurnace: hmmm
[2024-05-11 19:39:43] Gaijin: Before FNT stream
[2024-05-11 19:39:59] infinitelolz: well, still start from th most popular OVAs. the least popular are less popular for a reason
[2024-05-11 19:40:14] BlastFurnace: I have no problem with that
[2024-05-11 19:40:18] Anonymous: yeh i wanna rewatch unbalance already
[2024-05-11 19:40:18] BlastFurnace: lots of good choices on the nominations
[2024-05-11 19:40:20] anonwaha: sometimes it's "less popular" just cuz they have few votes
>>
No.67630
>B is practically making it every month without anything planned to keep teh "special feeling" of cytubes
I don't think it makes a difference either way if we're still ultimately hosting a stream once every month. The "keep it special" argument was what we used when streams were "once every 2 months" VS "once every month", not "once every month alternating between long and short" VS "once every month with the #1 voted show"

>I dont think it really matters
That's true, but it makes it easier to determine what we're watching if there's an established formula behind it

I'm personally in favor of B: if it's the #1 voted show, then that's what we'll watch (plus extras if it's really short and users are down for it)
>>
No.67632
>The "keep it special" argument was what we used when streams were "once every 2 months" VS "once every month"
yes, and A. was suggested as the middle way between two without anyone opposing
Personally I would liek B too if it means watching more anime with Heyuri overall, but we can't expect everyone to keep up with it, possibly leading to lower participation over time - unless we promote our streams across anime-focused imageboards somehow...
>>
No.67633
>but we can't expect everyone to keep up with it, possibly leading to lower participation over time
I don't think users choose to participate depending on how long the show is - rather, users choose to participate depending on what the show is, and whether their schedules allow for it. Obviously, it also depends on how many users are frequenting Heyuri as a whole

For teh Rozen Maiden stream (a well-loved, well-known, 1-cour length show), we had a max of 33 users and averaged 30-32 during the 1st half, around 25 during the 2nd half. I can't give exact numbers for previous streams since teh wiki is down, but I know that Rozen Maiden had a better turnout than many of the streams we've had this year (some of which were in the teens and low 20s IIRC)

That's why I say the run-time doesn't matter - users will participate if they're interested in the show and they're available, and since nominations are made and voted on by users, the show that users desire to watch the most is gonna be the one at the top
>>
No.67634
I like the way things are now but I'm up for watching whatever is rated the highest
>>
No.67638
I think we should make a poll to make it easier to see which more people prefer.
>>
No.67639
>I think we should make a poll to make it easier to see which more people prefer.
Wait! First we need to decide if we'll be going with the top-voted item in the poll or not wink
Delete post: []