[Return] [Bottom]

Posting mode: Reply

Emotes
Kaomoji
Emoji
BBCode
(for deletion)
  • Allowed file types are: gif, jpg, jpeg, png, bmp, webp, swf, webm, mp4
  • Maximum file size allowed is 50000 KB.
  • Images greater than 200 * 200 pixels will be thumbnailed.
  • 5 unique users in the last 10 minutes (including lurkers)




We will watch Arcade Gamer Fubuki (2002), Bakuen Campus Guardress (1994) and Teizokurei Daydream (2004) on the next Saturday 18:00 UTC [Info] [Countdown]

Want your banner here? Click here to submit yours!

File: image.jpg
[Spoiler](60 KB, 600x600) ▶
61673
Is contemporary manga black and white out of japanese cultural inertia? Seems like it would be relatively simple to colorize it, but it doesn't seem too popular for some reason.

Your fortune: Average luck

>>
tankoban can easily go over 200 pages, when you print a million books, with 200+ colored pages, it can get quite expensive.
>>
colorizing stuff requure effort
so if you are a solo writer you don't generaly do it
in italy solo comic writer avoid coloring as well
>>
It's a crunch even just to get black and white chapters out on schedule - color takes a lot longer
>>
American comics have "colorists" and even with that it still looks like crap, and the comics are like 3 pages.
>>
>>7321
> Seems like it would be relatively simple to colorize it, but it doesn't seem too popular for some reason.

Manga is cheap, colorizing it would make the printing twice as expensive. American comics used to be cheaper as well, until they started getting pushed to be colorized and needing to be printed on glossy paper instead of pulp.
>>
>>7321
>simple
hm... theres nothing simpler than being colorbl-
>>
>>7324
>>7325
arent tintin in color? maybe it's just the economy of the art.
>>
>>7321
>>7323
i think OP meant simple flat colors, which totally does not make superman or batman comic back then any shorter. Some black and whites end up bein shorter anyway.

Thus the answer is not the cultural inertia, it's ...the publisher's budget...since black and white is considered cheap nowadays regardless of whatever is going on.
>>
Actually mangakas have to draw 20 pages a week.

Also manga coloring isn't always good. Even when it's, not everyone might like it.
But with black & white your imagination creates the best version.
>>
>>7336
>Actually mangakas have to draw 20 pages a week.
It seems like a stressful juggling act figuring out the composition of each panel individually and in relation to the whole, together with navigating the contours of the story as it unfolds onto the page all within such a strict time limit. Guess you have to be really dedicated to do it.

>But with black & white your imagination creates the best version.
I like the way you put it toji :biggrin: There is a simple elegance in black and white which I find to be part of the allure.
>>
File: Watchmen 3.jpg
[Spoiler](743 KB, 1027x1600) ▶
761236
>>7321
Black and white is cheaper to print and quicker to produce, and lends its own sort of style to a work that colour can't really do. As the anon above this post said, there's a specific allure to black and white.

>>7335
Flat colours, like how old comic books were done, really don't look good. Not saying it can't -- Watchmen's colouring, (pic related, as an example) for instance, I would say is one of the comic's biggest strengths because of how it uses colours to create atmosphere, but most of the time it isn't done with this level of deliberateness and care.

Want your banner here? Click here to submit yours!

[Top]

Delete post: []
First
[1]
Last