all
a
/
b
/
c
/
f
/
h
/
j
/
jp
/
l
/
o
/
q
/
s
/
sw
/
lounge
cgi
up
wiki
Heyuri!
Bulletin Boards
2D Cute
2D Ero
2D Lolikon
3D Girls
Anime/Manga
Flash
Girl Talk
日本語/Japan
Lounge
Oekaki
Off-Topic
Site Discussion
Strange World
Overboard
Heyuri★CGI
Heyuri★CGI
@PartyII
Battle Royale R
Chat
Chinsouki★
Dating
DevChat
Drama Club
Hakoniwa Islands PvE
Hakoniwa Islands PvP
Polls
Slime Breeder
Web Banana
Web Shiritori
Yumemiru Gambler
Kakiko Checker
Other
Anime Nominations
Banners
Cytube
Heyuri Calendar
Heyuri Wiki
MAL Club
Museum
Steam Group
Uploader
[
Settings
]
[
Home
] [
Contact
] [
Catalog
] [
Search
] [
Thread list
] [
Stats
] [
Reports
] [
Watcher
] [
PMs
] [
Admin
]
Off-Topic@Heyuri
it's the place to be!
[
Return
]
Report a post
Preview
File:
you-wouldnt-steal-a-car-piracy-PSA.jpg
(199 KB, 1200x685)
ImgOps
Hide image
ImgOps
Hide image
▶
Copying with indirect harm
Bishopu
◆h4HfV64Q2c
[
PM
]
2025/08/24
(Sun)
02:53:58
No.
153699
[
Report
]
+
AS
▶
The copying of media dates pretty far back, though before it wasn't always wrong to do. Since the first copyright law, things have changed to call it 'Theft', and while it has a similar harm to it. It doesn't hit the definition.
Copying by itself is not wrong. if someone copies my laptop's specs and OS. It doesn't harm me at all. If they copied my data as well, now it's wrong. If I was intending to sell my laptop (deprived of all my data) and someone copies it then it's annoying but I can still sell it to the next guy. But if said copier, copies it for everyone then my laptop is worthless. Though it never left my hands, I was deprived of its value much like theft.
Externality seems to describe it best. The individual never directly touched anything and never had malicious intent however I was affected by their actions.
'Copying with negative externality' doesn't really roll off the tongue very well though. Is there a better term for this?
To layer on the question further, is ai scraping the artstyle of an artist negative externality? A friend of mine trained an ai model to near perfectly mimic his chosen artist's style. He used to commission and give money but now he doesn't have to, now he can print away his anime waifu without waiting, without needing to go back and forth with artist to get the character just right and for free! (well he's paying for servers so not quite free). Even worse damage if he releases this model online to others.
What do you think anons? What kind of seven seas have you plundered in your years?
Is it wrong to copy files and artstyles? In basic morality it harms another. Admitting-ly I do it all time for movies and games.
ヽ(´ー`)ノ
oh well, karma will judge me.
Post number
No.
153699
Board
Off-Topic@Heyuri
Reason
Optional. Describe what's wrong with it.
Style: